Roofing Today

Testing Gutter Guards: The Verdict

Here at Roofing Today, we have had several roofing contractors comment to us on the problems they come across regarding blocked gutters.

Contractors often get calls from property owners and managers who mistakenly think the roof is leaking. On investigation it turns out that there is a gutter block, often caused by leaves from overhanging trees or moss growth on the roof. The result is that gutters are regularly overflowing and causing building damage.

A few years ago, when the gutter brush systems first came on the market, contractors thought they had found a simple, cost-effective solution to offer clients. Indeed, new builds were incorporating gutter brushes at the time of construction to counter known risks, for example from trees which had to be retained to gain planning for the development. Great, problem solved!

But then contractors found they were getting angry callbacks. They would return to find that the gutter brush or infill systems they’d installed were impeding rainwater flow, in itself causing overflows, or the systems were accumulating debris and getting blocked so frequently they’d become more hindrance than help.

Liability

The problem was highlighted by Doug Basen of Local Authority Building Control when he cautioned inspectors to advise clients to choose anti-blocking gutter systems carefully. Citing Building Regulations part H3, and BS EN 12056- 3:2000 Clause 7.3.3, which states ‘the reduction in outlet capacity due to strainers being installed shall be taken into consideration’, Doug warned that installers might find themselves liable if they had fitted a product which ultimately caused damage to a building.

Doug compared the various products on offer, assessing rainwater flow rates when they’re installed.

Three products were examined: firstly, foam, fibre, rubber or acrylic systems, designed to sit in the gutter and absorb water moving it to a downpipe without allowing any material to find its way into the system. Secondly, gutter brushes were evaluated: also designed to sit in the gutter and catch debris while still permitting waterflow. Thirdly, gutter guards, which are a mesh fitted to the open top of the gutter.

After conducting his investigation Doug concluded: “It would seem the first two examples will immediately cause a reduction in flow capacity as a direct result of their installation. The moral  here is make sure you do check if guttering anti- blockage has been incorporated before completion, and, if it has, that the flow rate of the gutter has not been impeded.”

Mesh gutter guards are the clear winner here because, sitting on the top of the gutter, they clearly don’t impede water flow.

Not all equal

But, not all gutter guards are created equal. In fact, a mesh construction allowing for a slope is vital: flat gutter guards do not perform optimally. If the gutter mesh is not sloped towards the outer edge of the gutter where it’s fitted, it risks leaves still accumulating on the mesh surface where they will start to decompose and form a mulch, over which rainwater can run off. Whereas a sloped mesh will help debris to sluice harmlessly of the mesh surface, while rainwater is channelled away.

Tests conducted by the Building Research Establishment (BRE) to the principle of BS EN 12056-3-2000 confirm these findings. BRE tests showed that, firstly, any product that sits within the gutter can impede rainwater flow by as much as 50-80%.

The BRE trials established a normal gutter flow rate baseline of 120l/m (picture 1). This was compared to a a typical accumulation of leaves with a downpipe ‘balloon’ filter fitted, causing an 80% reduction in the flow rate of rainwater to 25l/m. (picture 2). A gutter brush installation showed a flowrate of 60l/m – a reduction of 50%.

(picture 3); while a rigid flat mesh gutter guard had a flowrate of 18%, reducing the flow to 98l/m (picture 4). The mesh of Gutter Flo showed no impact on the flowrate, remaining at 120l/m (picture 5).

Roofing Today’s Verdict

  • Contractors need to be aware of their own professional liability and ensure they install products that don’t impede water flow.
  • Choose a mesh gutter guard that does not affect water flow – remember a sloped surface is vital.
  • Choose an easy to install system that can adapt to different eaves constructions, roofing and guttering materials.
Normal Gutter Flow
Leaves Accumulation Gutter
Gutter Brush Installation
Mesh Gutter Guard
GutterFlo Test